Food52’s Piglet Tournament of Cookbooks: Tasting Rome vs. Taste of Persia

By Brian Lemay 21 comments


Hey everyone! Food52 is one of my favorite food web sites and culinary resources. Every year they hold this epic cookbook challenge called The Piglet. This year they asked me to be a judge and I was so honored, I couldn’t say no. The two books they assigned me were: Tasting Rome: Fresh Flavors and Forgotten Recipes From an Ancient City. And Taste of Persia: A Cook’s Travels through Armenia, Azerbaijan Georgia, Iran and Kurdistan. Tasting Rome, Taste of Persia, let’s take another part of the world, shall we? Both cookbooks are culinary travelogues, they’re about places just as much as they are about food. In fact, these two cookbooks make the case for the two being inseparable. And lucky for me, I adore both of these cuisines. I couldn’t wait to dive in. The authors of each book walk us through the streets they described so beautifully, even journalistically. In Tasting Rome, by Katie Parla and Kristina Gill, I felt like I was walking through the cobblestone streets of Rome with them. Each photo, taken by the very talented Kristina Gill, is impeccably and gorgeously composed. It’s a fun walk, and with Katie Parla’s entertaining descriptions, you peek into different cafes and homes and you get a series of snapshots of what life is like in this city. Stunning aesthetics. Mission accomplished; I was already daydreaming of a trip to Rome. Parla and Gill wooed me. You can’t judge a book by it’s cover, and yet, of course, we all do. So my initial impression of Tasting Rome was more favorable because I felt like it would be so hard to top. Then I picked up Naomi Duguid’s Taste of Persia to familiarize myself with, as she says, “Cuisines Without Borders.” These photos feel more journalistic, but the content is so compelling you slide inside the pages. She took all the photos herself while she traveled solo through these countries, which, food aside, is incredibly impressive to me. As I flipped the pages, I again felt transported. But this time I was in her shoes. So in Georgia, for instance, I would get a peek, then investigate. I’d spy a woman making khachapuri, then go up to her door frame and be welcomed into her home. I’d watch her and her friends make khachapuri, then sit with them on the grass talking and drinking Georgian red wine. I really feel like I got to know the author while reading this, so I’ll call her Naomi. Hope you don’t mind. Naomi emphasizes the people behind the food and brings them close. The people behind the news headlines we read about, the part of the world that can feel so alien. And the food! Oh man, my appetite was cheering about so many of the recipes found in Persia. I love the Italian food from Tasting Rome, but the Persian dishes lured me into that world. And I was drooling over everything! By the time I finished my first pass of each book, I discovered that Tasting Rome was sprinkled with sticky notes, whereas Taste of Persia was absolutely littered with them. I wanted to make everything Naomi described. The first issue I came upon was at the grocery store. Both books sometimes call for difficult to source ingredients. Fennel pollen, from Rome, and blue fenugreek, from Persia, are not going to be found at your local grocery store. Even my Brooklyn Whole Foods couldn’t help me there. Luckily the authors of both books have the home cook in mind and do offer suggestions for online specialty store recommendations. You can get by without an ingredient hiccup through most of Tasting Rome and Taste of Persia occasionally offers substitutes you can use instead. Tasting Rome is not organized like most cookbooks, by traditional courses, but rather collections of, for example, the classics and dishes from specific Roman communities, such as the dozen pages devoted to Cucina Ebraica: Jewish culture and cuisine in Rome. One of my favorite dishes from this book was from that chapter: the pumpkin frittata. Really, all the dishes I made from this cookbook were delicious. My favorite was the beef rolls, in which thinly sliced rump roast meat is wrapped with prosciutto around julienned carrots and celery, then is slow-cooked in a tomato and wine sauce until the meat just falls apart. My fiancé Connor loved the rice-stuffed tomatoes surrounded by chunks of potato. And I enjoyed trying my hand at the classic carbonara. But with many dishes, I had recipe questions along the way. I wanted clarification. Like when I was roasting the peeled cherry tomatoes for the garlic, oil, peperoncino and roasted tomatoes dish, I wanted a visual cue: what should the final tomatoes look like? Like, how roasted should they be? I ended up just guessing. Taste of Persia’s table of contents is organized more traditionally: by salads and vegetables, soups, fish, sweets, etc. Naomi further breaks up each of those sections by country and expounds on regionally specific distinctions within each category. The dishes I made were so stinking good! They were simple and hearty. Pomegranate-walnut chicken stew was ridiculously easy for that addicting burst of flavor surrounding and infusing the bites of tender meat. Spinach borani was something that I’d welcome as a side dish to just about any meal on my plate. Baked Persian rice that, to me, exemplifies comfort food. And a lot of the recipes are quite healthy, although that’s not something that Naomi emphasizes. Culture and flavor trump in Persia. She’s more of an anthropologist than a chef. I appreciate that her recipes are just as approachable to a home cook as her travel anecdotes are entertaining and informative. I so enjoyed her stories and somehow felt more of an understanding of, and connection with, the food I was preparing and eating because of it. I thoroughly enjoyed both of these cookbooks, but alas, I must choose a winner. Because Taste of Persia will remain on my kitchen shelf whereas Tasting Rome will likely make its way to my coffee table, Taste of Persia wins. Thanks for watching and, as always, keep it quirky!

21 Comments

Cherish York

Mar 3, 2017, 1:16 pm Reply

That was really interesting! I may have to find that book.

Jason Chappel

Mar 3, 2017, 1:56 pm Reply

Thank you for the great review and video, Katie!

375F

Mar 3, 2017, 2:18 pm Reply

A really wonderful review ๐Ÿ™‚

Willian Paupรฉrio

Mar 3, 2017, 3:38 pm Reply

I still don't know how you only have 27k subs!!! You are cool and your videos are short but complete!
Found you a week ago looking for some brazilians recipes cooked by americans.
You deserve at least 100K subs!!
I love your channel.
Greetings from Brazil! ๐Ÿ™‚

Renata Franco

Mar 3, 2017, 5:30 pm Reply

I don't know if I am crazy, but they are some political understones in this video that I really like, haha.

Edgar Barguiarena

Mar 3, 2017, 6:05 pm Reply

Aaaaand now I'll be trying out some Persian recipes this weekend. Thanks for the inspiration Katie!

suallenparker

Mar 3, 2017, 6:59 pm Reply

Thank you so much for sharing that experience with us! It gave me Julie/Julia-flashbacks, if that means something to you. The Taste of Persia looks so good, both the recipes and the stories! I might have to buy it โ€ฆ Thank you for making this video! I loved watching it. ๐Ÿ™‚

Taj William

Mar 3, 2017, 7:52 pm Reply

Your nose is obese

Kata Balรกzs

Mar 3, 2017, 8:40 pm Reply

wow, I instantly searched for the books. ๐Ÿ™‚ thanks Katie for this longer video, I really enjoyed, you should review cookbooks more often!

Gino Salinas

Mar 3, 2017, 9:43 pm Reply

Didn't know about your channel, just came here because I was interested in Tasting Rome, but now, thanks to this video I'm pretty sure I'm getting both of the books, plus I'm subscribing to your channel. Wonderful review and great quality. Congratulations from Mexico for your good work!

Teresa Reyes

Mar 3, 2017, 1:56 am Reply

๐Ÿ˜๐Ÿ˜๐Ÿ˜๐Ÿ˜๐Ÿ˜๐Ÿ˜๐Ÿ˜๐Ÿ˜

Twenty Two Plates

Mar 3, 2017, 2:07 am Reply

Thanks for the in-depth reviews! History, culture and food all my favorite things! You definitly peaked my interest in these cookbooks!

Patricia Murray

Mar 3, 2017, 12:18 pm Reply

Thanks, I just discovered a cookbook to get for my dad's upcoming birthday!

Krista Simmons

Mar 3, 2017, 8:29 pm Reply

love katie parla and "tasting rome." will have to check out "taste of persia!"

Amanda Frederickson

Mar 3, 2017, 7:52 pm Reply

I need to get both books! They look stunning and totally delicious.

Rebecca Allison

Mar 3, 2017, 10:13 pm Reply

Well done reviews. So interesting. Made me hungry. You are going to love London and your access to Europe. Hope your move goes smoothly.

fanzy1338

Mar 3, 2017, 4:47 pm Reply

I love Persian cuisine but closest Persian restaurant is nearly 200 miles drive. I guess my best option is to buy the book and make it at home.

PrincessMooncake

Mar 3, 2017, 11:23 pm Reply

Hi! I just found your channel from Brothers Green Eats and I love your channel!!!!! You rock, keep it quirky! Hugs from California ๐Ÿ™‚

John G

Apr 4, 2017, 1:32 am Reply

I really liked the logical progression of your decision tree–not having seen either of the books myself, so I don't have a preference either way. This is a nice, thoughtful analysis. Thank you, Katie.

SmokeAlot nd6

Jun 6, 2019, 1:49 am Reply

Modern Byzantium-Sassanid war

Shaun M

Jul 7, 2019, 8:16 am Reply

This is a fair comparison. I also really love and use Taste of Persia. Great job!

Leave a Reply